S.E. Cupp receives a “B,” but let’s not forget the curve

A number of people are criticizing S.E. Cupp’s Daily News article, “Pot could put progressives in a tough spot”. And, indeed, it’s pretty bad.

Here’s my attempt at subjecting parts of the article to the kind of criticism I give to student papers:

The same argument used against guns is used for pot: that legalizing pot and making it more available will reduce crime (Source?) No good liberal would say the same of guns, though there is substantial evidence to prove more guns equal less crime. (Such as?)

We’re told (Indefinite pronoun. Define “we.” And “told” by whom?) pot users will “responsibly” use marijuana in the privacy of their own homes. (This appears to be a direct quote. What’s your source?) But what barometer are they (Indefinite pronoun. Antecedent has not been identified.) using to determine that persistent recreational drug users, who have presumably broken the law before by possessing marijuana, are responsible people? (Non sequitur.) And why aren’t lawful gun owners afforded the same level of trust?

If progressives want to keep gun control “gun use” in the crosshairs – and many have said they do (Such as?) – they’ll have to reconcile this intellectual incongruity. (False equivalence.)

—snip—

A successfully-delivered state-run program would send a clear signal that government functions (“can function”) more effectively at the smaller, local level and that federal bureaucracy, whether in drug enforcement or, say, health care, can only (“sometimes”) muck things up. (Logical fallacy. See #1 below…)

*****

1. A single case proves little or nothing, as explained by this example found at the web page, Some Definitions of Science, posted by Dr. Bruce Railsback, from the University of Georgia:

A carpenter, a school teacher, and scientist were traveling by train through Scotland when they saw a black sheep through the window of the train.

“Aha,” said the carpenter with a smile, “I see that Scottish sheep are black.”

“Hmm,” said the school teacher, “You mean that some Scottish sheep are black.”

“No,” said the scientist glumly, “All we know is that there is at least one sheep in Scotland, and that at least one side of that one sheep is black.”

All we know is that there is at least one instance in the U.S. where state drug law has gone against the Federal government. Extrapolating this to all State vs. Federal government issues can lead to controversy. C.f. the history of the Thirteenth Amendment for more information.

Share this:
Share this page via Email Share this page via Stumble Upon Share this page via Digg this Share this page via Facebook Share this page via Twitter
This entry was posted in Criticism, History, Politics, Rhetoric. Bookmark the permalink.

255 Responses to S.E. Cupp receives a “B,” but let’s not forget the curve

  1. Pingback: cheap louis vuitton

  2. Pingback: エルメス ワイキキ

  3. Pingback: ray ban sunglasses

  4. Pingback: coach outlet

  5. Pingback: http://www.familylifeinstitute.org/newshoes/NIKE/533VsE0Jcb.html

  6. Pingback: coach factory outlet online

  7. Pingback: セリーヌ バッグ

  8. Pingback: Nike KD 7 DMV

  9. Pingback: cheap jordan shoes

  10. Pingback: Legend blue 11s

  11. Pingback: jordan 11 pantone

  12. Pingback: michael kors black friday 2014

  13. Pingback: jordan 11 speckle

  14. Pingback: cheap uggs uk

  15. Pingback: jordan 1 sport blue

  16. Pingback: Legend blue 11 for sale

  17. Pingback: prada リボン 財布

  18. Pingback: louis vuitton purses

  19. Pingback: pandora charms

  20. Pingback: genuine ugg boots

  21. Pingback: black Oreo 6s

  22. Pingback: ugg boots clearance

  23. Pingback: cheap uggs for sale

  24. Pingback: Foamposites elephant print

  25. Pingback: coach handbags

  26. Pingback: Retro 11

  27. Pingback: ugg boots cheap

  28. Pingback: Lebron 9

  29. Pingback: pandora bracelet

  30. Pingback: http://garden-gate.net/tokyobags/MICHAELKORS/PJ0dp9mKkX.html

  31. Pingback: uggs clearance

  32. Pingback: jordan retro 11

  33. Pingback: buy cheap ugg boots

  34. Pingback: Jordan 13 blackout

  35. Pingback: Brazil 6s

  36. Pingback: fast weight loss

  37. Pingback: http://www.childersphoto.com/bags/Cartier/6LQm70oSK3.html

  38. Pingback: jordan 6 retro black infrared

  39. Pingback: foamposites yeezys

  40. Pingback: http://holani.net/YAMAHA/TKW2ZZAJO9.html

  41. Pingback: coach outlet online

  42. Pingback: fitflops

  43. Pingback: uggs on sale

  44. Pingback: mulberry outlet

  45. Pingback: michael kors hamilton

  46. Pingback: louis vuitton purses

  47. Pingback: Legend blue 11s

  48. Pingback: jordan retro 11

  49. Pingback: hologram 13s

  50. Pingback: zapatillas baratas

  51. Pingback: jordan 6

  52. Pingback: jordan 439

  53. Pingback: cheap louis vuitton

  54. Pingback: cheap lebron 12

  55. Pingback: ugg boots outlet online

  56. Pingback: Where To Buy Sport Blue 6s

  57. Pingback: Lebron 11

  58. Pingback: ugg outlet

  59. Pingback: air max 90

  60. Pingback: gucci torino

  61. Pingback: mbt shoes

  62. Pingback: Cheap Christian Louboutin Black Patent Leather Flo 120mm Pumps Free Shipping

  63. Pingback: ugg boots outlet

  64. Pingback: http://www.airporttransmission.com/tokyojewelry/Swarovski/kKkUCLJrCg.html

  65. Pingback: north face

  66. Pingback: cheap uggs

  67. Pingback: gucci firenze on line

  68. Pingback: グッチ キーケース 人気

  69. Pingback: uggs outlet

  70. Pingback: Tory Burch公式ホームページ

  71. Pingback: http://www.commercialglassnc.com/jewelry/MIKIMOTO/NqF1GXSxmP.html

  72. Pingback: cheap lebron james shoes

  73. Pingback: hollister shop deutschland

  74. Pingback: Luxury Christian Louboutin Nude Ron Ron Zeppa 100mm For Sale

  75. Pingback: discount ugg boots

  76. Pingback: louis vuitton handbags

  77. Pingback: jordan 11 retro Legend blue

  78. Pingback: http://maxmicrochip.com/bags/MIUMIU/zlkX14wge5.html

  79. Pingback: Wolf grey 3s

  80. Pingback: canada goose black friday 2014

  81. Pingback: nike Lebron 12 Lion Heart

  82. Pingback: Jordan Sport Blue 6s

  83. Pingback: jordan 3 5lab3

  84. Pingback: louis vuitton black friday 2014

  85. Pingback: barbour

  86. Pingback: Lebron 11 Everglades

  87. Pingback: kate spade diaper bag

  88. Pingback: Legend blue 11s

  89. Pingback: http://grafkellerinvestor.com/?id=17

  90. Pingback: mulberry outlet

  91. Pingback: Cheap Air Jordans

  92. Pingback: isabel marant sneakers

  93. Pingback: mulberry bags

  94. Pingback: louis vuitton bags

  95. Pingback: Ray Ban RB3025 Aviator lunette Discount R15

  96. Pingback: jimmy choo shoes

  97. Pingback: Columbia 11s

  98. Pingback: Sport Blue 6s Online

  99. Pingback: nike lebron 12

  100. Pingback: louis vuitton sale

  101. Pingback: ugg boots sale uk

  102. Pingback: michael kors wallet

  103. Pingback: Jordan 11 Infrared 23

  104. Pingback: discount uggs

  105. Pingback: nike roshe run for sale

  106. Pingback: Real Sport Blue 6s

  107. Pingback: tory burch black friday 2014

  108. Pingback: jordan retro 6

  109. Pingback: louis vuitton purses

  110. Pingback: red wing shoes

  111. Pingback: lebron 12

  112. Pingback: http://www.123compusoft.com/YAMAHA/kYCV2LY8IX.html

  113. Pingback: oakley sunglasses

  114. Pingback: jordan black friday

  115. Pingback: ugg boots sale clearance

  116. Pingback: jordan 11 legend blue

  117. Pingback: Louis Vuitton Bags

  118. Pingback: Toro 4s

  119. Pingback: louis vuitton outlet

  120. Pingback: ugg boots sale

  121. Pingback: jordan 13s

  122. Pingback: jordan 13s

  123. Pingback: best diet plans

  124. Pingback: louis vuitton sale

  125. Pingback: http://www.wijnenjacqueline.com/carshop/HarleyDavidson/skqnMBy6f3.html

  126. Pingback: jordan 13 3m

  127. Pingback: gucci handbags

  128. Pingback: jordan 6 white carmine

  129. Pingback: guess outlet store

  130. Pingback: kate spade handbags

  131. Pingback: magasin hermes paris

  132. Pingback: uggs sale clearance

  133. Pingback: michael kors outlet store

  134. Pingback: furla handbags

  135. Pingback: michael kors outlet online

  136. Pingback: lebron 12

  137. Pingback: miu miu handbags

  138. Pingback: tiffany & co

  139. Pingback: retro 6 black infrared

  140. Pingback: pantone 11s

  141. Pingback: http://www.ettelecom.co.im/?id=369

  142. Pingback: jordan 11 legend blue

  143. Pingback: http://www.nfjc-ksa.com/tokyobags/BALENCIAGA/JIlpbxL67P.html

  144. Pingback: http://www.core-bp.com/tokyojpbags/ThinkBee/6RAI6G3dSn.html

  145. Pingback: Infrared 23 Low 11s

  146. Pingback: louis vuitton bags

  147. Pingback: http://www.thefountaininc.net/tokyojpclothes/Formalbusiness/9Fbk5BYIQW.html

  148. Pingback: Tory Burch メンズ

  149. Pingback: louis vuitton outlet

  150. Pingback: Columbia 11s

  151. Pingback: Oakley 5 Sunglasses Jacksonville Fl

  152. Pingback: Christian Louboutin Lou Spikes 45

  153. Pingback: new jordans 2014

  154. Pingback: roshes nike

  155. Pingback: http://www.ourhomeconnections.com/Fender/58bnB59gY7.html

  156. Pingback: louis vuitton outlet

  157. Pingback: Infrared White 11s

  158. Pingback: New Style Christian Louboutin Black Stiletto Anemone 120mm For Sale

  159. Pingback: Christian Louboutin Men Fred Clous US 10.5

  160. Pingback: gucci outlet

  161. Pingback: ralph lauren polo shirts

  162. Pingback: Wholesale Christian Louboutin Nude Patent Leather Almeria 120mm Wedges For Sale

  163. Pingback: jordan 11s

  164. Pingback: Largest Discount Christian Louboutin Red Ysa 100mm For Sale

  165. Pingback: cheap jordan shoes

  166. Pingback: エルメス 財布 イメージ

  167. Pingback: louis vuitton belt

  168. Pingback: jordan 6 retro black infrared

  169. Pingback: What The Lebron 11

  170. Pingback: セリーヌ バッグ lush

  171. Pingback: Lance Mountain 1s

  172. Pingback: jordan 6 white carmine

  173. Pingback: mbt shoes

  174. Pingback: china

  175. Pingback: giuseppe zanotti shoes

  176. Pingback: michael kors bags

  177. Pingback: tory burch shoes

  178. Pingback: Legend blue 11s

  179. Pingback: burberry outlet

  180. Pingback: http://embroidery.smvinc.com/tokyoclothes/STUSSY/go3XBtCrbQ.html

  181. Pingback: Low Price Christian Louboutin Gwendoline 100mm Suedeleather For Sale

  182. Pingback: Luxury Christian Louboutin Stiletto Anemone 120mm Leather For Sale

  183. Pingback: louis vuitton outlet

  184. Pingback: jordan 11 legend blue

  185. Pingback: ugg boots on sale

  186. Pingback: chi hair products

  187. Pingback: foamposites yeezys for sale

  188. Pingback: グッチ バッグ 最安値

  189. Pingback: parajumper jackets

  190. Pingback: fendi belts

  191. Pingback: Infrared 23 Low 11s

  192. Pingback: Fashion Style Christian Louboutin You You 100mm Strass For Sale

  193. Pingback: www.warrock.ph/?id=573

  194. Pingback: jordan 11s

  195. Pingback: Cheap Christian Louboutin Blue Rantus

  196. Pingback: http://catbrewingco.com/bags/hermes/nlQn3z4j92.html

  197. Pingback: Discount Christian Louboutin Pivoine Patent Leather You You 100mm Pumps For Sale

  198. Pingback: nike lebron 12

  199. Pingback: Cheap Christian Louboutin Black Patent Leather You You Sling 100mm Platforms Hot Sale

  200. Pingback: christian louboutin outlet

  201. Pingback: louis vuitton bags cheap uk

  202. Pingback: loui vuitton

  203. Pingback: Latest Christian Louboutin Blue Madame Butterfly 140mm For Sale

  204. Pingback: nike roshe run mens

  205. Pingback: Ugg Metallic Boots

  206. Pingback: mac cosmetics coupons

  207. Pingback: roshes nike

  208. Pingback: jordan 6 black infrared

  209. Pingback: 3m 13s

  210. Pingback: nike lebron 12

  211. Pingback: Buy Sport Blue 6s

  212. Pingback: roshe run nike

  213. Pingback: babyliss pro

  214. Pingback: foamposites for sale

  215. Pingback: coach outlet

  216. Pingback: infrared speckle 11s

  217. Pingback: louboutin homme

  218. Pingback: sac lancel solde

  219. Pingback: mcm outlet

  220. Pingback: http://move.quiltsfromtheheart.org/tokyoshoes/Jeans/efEppyBAZH.html

  221. Pingback: Lebron 11

  222. Pingback: jordan 6 retro pantone

  223. Pingback: black Oreo 6s

  224. Pingback: uggs for cheap

  225. Pingback: Replica Black Christian Louboutin Altadama 140mm Watersnake

  226. Pingback: Cheap Christian Louboutin Black Paulina 100mm

  227. Pingback: jordan 11 legend blue

  228. Pingback: roshe nike

  229. Pingback: Replica Christian Louboutin Black Leather Lady Clou 140mm Platforms For Sale

  230. Pingback: Loui Vuitton

  231. Pingback: brazil 6s

  232. Pingback: louis vuitton purses

  233. Pingback: wolf grey 3s for sale

  234. Pingback: Buy Cheap Christian Louboutin Black Leather Daf Freak 160mm Pumps Buy Cheap With Free Shipping

  235. Pingback: juicy couture handbags

  236. Pingback: history of jordan 6s

  237. Pingback: kate spade diaper bag

  238. Pingback: jordan retro 11 legend blue

  239. Pingback: Concord 11s

  240. Pingback: Legend blue 11

  241. Pingback: venom green 6s for sale

  242. Pingback: louis vuitton purses

  243. Pingback: uggs outlet stores

  244. Pingback: ugg uk

  245. Pingback: black toe 14s

  246. Pingback: Brown Christian Louboutin Melides 140mm Linen On Sale

  247. Pingback: Wholesale Christian Louboutin Silver Lady Peep Sling 140mm For Sale

  248. Pingback: louis vuitton purse

  249. Pingback: cheap lebron 12

  250. Pingback: jordan 13 3m

  251. Pingback: loui vuitton

  252. Pingback: beats by dre black friday 2014

  253. Pingback: jordan 11 retro Legend blue

  254. Pingback: Jordan 6 Retro Sport Blue

  255. Pingback: New Style Michael Kors Outlet Online

Leave a Reply